Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Comics Adaptation: FANTASTIC FOUR (heide) vs TRANSMETROPOLITAN

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Comics Adaptation: FANTASTIC FOUR (heide) vs TRANSMETROPOLITAN



    vs




    1. Showrunner/Director: Darren Aronofsky
    A huge comic book fan, Aronofsky has been linked to various comic book adaptations in the past, including Batman and Wolverine. He's created comic book tie-ins for his movies The Fountain and Noah. But he's not the director for a straight forward superhero movie. His worlds are too dirty, too real for that. He's a science fiction director who can stay within budget. Which is needed for this project.


    2. Antagonist: Edward Norton as The Smiler
    The Smiler is a two-faced bastard. Friendly and smiling in one moment, with an evil grin in the next. His image is that of the last honest politician, a loving family man. But in reality, he's a scheming manipulator who lets his family and friends die in accidents whenever it benefits his political career. Norton has built his whole career on split personalities. Primal Fear, Fight Club, Incredible Hulk... There's nobody better for this role than him.


    3. Protagonist: John C. McGinley as Spider Jerusalem
    He's a cynical journalist armed with a laptop and a bowel disuptor. He's the only man smart enough to see through the Smiler's plans. He is the only one powerful enough to take the fucker down.
    Who else but John C. McGinley? He looks the part, he played a cynical but highly intelligent man for years on Scrubs, and he works on a tv budget.


    4. Love Interest: Rachael Leigh Cook as Yelena Rossini
    As the niece of Spider's editor, she starts out as his clean, almost shy assistant. But Spider's influence on her makes her smarter - and more depraved. By the time he's done with her, she's turned into him, cigarettes, tattoos and all.
    Rachael Leigh Cook is versatile and pretty enough to play both sides.


    5. Supporting Character: Lelee Sobieski as Channon Yarrow.
    At the beginning of Transmetropolitan, she is a stripper. She assists Spider on his first mission back in the city - and becomes his assistant and bodyguard afterwards. Leelee Sobieski has the looks, but can kick ass if necessary.


    6: Storyline: Transmetropolitan #1-60
    William Gibson meets Frost/Nixon.
    A cyberpunk tale in a not-too-distant future, about the last journalist with the balls to mess with the President. Warren Ellis' masterpiece, and one of Vertigo's most successful books. Mandatory reading. And it would work nicely as an AMC or HBO series. Five seasons, twelve episodes each. Perfect.[/QUOTE]
    8
    Fantastic Four (Heide)
    37.50%
    3
    Transmetropolitan
    62.50%
    5

    The poll is expired.


  • #2
    You had me at Dr. Cox for Spider Jerusalem.

    Comment


    • #3
      I still can't picture Jesse throwing a punch. Or being a ladies man.

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by W.West View Post
        I still can't picture Jesse throwing a punch. Or being a ladies man.

        ...Oh, Heide's adaptation is live-action? With Brad Bird directing, I'd assumed it was some sort of animated project.

        Comment


        • #5
          He said this in the thread:

          View Post
          Alice Eve looked exactly like Susan Storm in MIB 3. So I needed an actor that was slightly younger than her and looked even younger than he is. He needed to be versatile enough to pull off drama and comedic relief. And he must not be too tied to another comic book franchise, because not everyone can pull off a Chris Evans and kill as both Johnny Storm and Steve Rogers.
          Eisenberg has proven that he can play both ends of the spectrum (Social Network, Zombieland), so he quickly moved to the top of the list. Other actors I considered were Michael Cera (who I couldn't take seriously in dramatic scenes), Logan Lerman (too young), Alex Pettyfer (ugh), Justin Timberlake (I'd rather not), Cillian Murphy (too old, also Scarecrow), Nicholas Hoult (who is already Beast), and yes, Garrett Hedlund (looks too old, even though he is technically two years younger than Alice).

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by W.West View Post
            He said this in the thread:

            Yeah, I don't know how I missed that. Either way my vote's already been cast, but it wouldn't have changed my mind much. Sorry, Heide.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by fearless2814.1 View Post
              ...Oh, Heide's adaptation is live-action? With Brad Bird directing, I'd assumed it was some sort of animated project.
              Don't forget that he also directed Mission Impossible 4.

              Comment


              • #8
                Originally posted by Michael Heide View Post
                Don't forget that he also directed Mission Impossible 4.

                He DID?! Seriously?

                Comment


                • #9
                  Originally posted by fearless2814.1 View Post
                  He DID?! Seriously?
                  Yes. It was his first (and so far as I know, only) live-action film.

                  Comment


                  • #10
                    Catch up Fearless.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X