The only way Magneto should beat John is if magnetism can affect the GL ring. I'm assuming that is not the case, given Doctor Polaris's poor showings against GL.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
ATENTION!!! ALL JOHN STEWART and LANTERN FANS
Collapse
X
-
-
I'm assuming we're talking about Sam Alexander as Nova, in which case I'd certainly pick John. A Nova Corps helmet is similar to a GL ring in many ways, but it doesn't make constructs (at least that I can remember) and John's tactical mind seems like it would easily best Sam's.Check out my Green Lantern product reviews on Twitter as the Emerald Enthusiast! @EmeraldEnthusi1
Comment
-
Yo.
Originally posted by Mister Ed View PostThe only way Magneto should beat John is if magnetism can affect the GL ring. I'm assuming that is not the case, given Doctor Polaris's poor showings against GL.
Tazer
Originally posted by Andrew NDBGeoff Johns should have a 10 mile restraining order from comic books, let alone films.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Tazer View PostYo.
to be fair, if we look at both Mags & Polaris' showings in-comic (and I say this as somebody who has seen alot of BOTH characters): Id side w/Mags every time, and I think he'd give most GLs a good run for their money.
That being the case, even though Magneto is far more competent than Doctor Polaris, he seems overmatched against a GL. The ability to yank the ring away would be the only real way I'd see him winning.
Comment
-
Yo.
if U have the ish handy, I would point ya to v2 #133 when Polaris was able to set up a forcefield around Hals Ring which put a stranglehold on his effectiveness, eventually leading him to giving up during their fight in the Docs base.
Tazer
Originally posted by Andrew NDBGeoff Johns should have a 10 mile restraining order from comic books, let alone films.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Tazer View PostYo.
if U have the ish handy, I would point ya to v2 #133 when Polaris was able to set up a forcefield around Hals Ring which put a stranglehold on his effectiveness, eventually leading him to giving up during their fight in the Docs base.
Which is why these X vs. Y comparisons all REALLY have an answer that is dependent on who is writing it, and in whose book it takes place.
Comment
Comment