Enter the Green Lantern Corps Message Board

 

Green Lantern Corps #18

Published November 29th, 2007
Writer : Peter J. Tomasi
Pencillers : Patrick Gleason & Jamal Igle
Inkers : Prentis Rollins & Jerry Ordway
Cover : Andy Kubert & Moose Baumann

Review by Andrew NDB
of

Here we have Peter J. Tomasi's debut issue of GLC, taking up the reins from the very capable Dave Gibbons. I will sorely miss Dave, and can't speak higher of what he brought to the past issues, Recharge, and everything he's contributed to Green Lantern all the way back to the 80s.

Still... the king is dead, long live the king. If Dave Gibbons seemed to excel in plot-driven storylines, what Mr. Tomasi does right out of the gate is a straight-out character piece. Geoff Johns indicated this issue would very much parallel the Superman-Prime special, only for Sodam Yat -- absolutely, that is exactly what we got.

I think it was a great issue and did exactly what it needed to (if a little late in the game, but who's keeping track?). We got into Sodam's head, got us to understand what makes him tick, gives him a backstory, and a good deal of his fight with Superman Prime (and though I was satisfied here, I have more than a sinking suspicion we haven't seen the last of Sodam by the end of #25... though I might be dead wrong).

The issue's story? Again, we do get a knock-down, drag-out fight with Sodam Yat and Superman-Prime, and get a good deal of much deserved backstory on Sodam at last. We get into his head, we learn a bit of what makes him tick, what's driving him, and I will venture this issue will probably serve to push those fans feeling a little rushed about Sodam's push over the fence in his favor... if they don't mind seeing him basically getting trounced (and perhaps that was necessary, to counterbalance his rapid rise in stature in the Corps... now we can see him pick up the pieces, and perhaps become a better man/a better character as a result).

The bad: not much, really. Two things stick out in my mind:

1) This is Sodam Yat's debut as Ion... yet we don't really see him -- at least apparently -- using any of the Ion power. If someone asked me, based on this issue alone, to explain how Sodam Yat, as Ion, (apart from his Kryptonian-esque Daxamite physiology rendering his physical body impervious) is any more powerful than your average Corps ring-wielder... I'd be at a loss to explain, really. We desperately need some kind of better understanding of exactly what the power of Ion portends (to say nothing of how it came to be in Kyle originally, but maybe Marz's tale next month will shed some light and that's not really Tomasi's problem here).

2) Daxam. It was destroyed in "Our Worlds at War." The backstory doesn't necessarily negate that, but it makes us present ourselves with two possibilities: A) He was recruited by the Corps probably almost immediately prior to Emerald Twilight, left powerless for a couple of years, and then re-recruited after Rebirth, or B) Daxam wasn't destroyed, is still out there somewhere and OWAW isn't canon anymore. Though B is probably what was intended, I think A is possible -- and probably a story in there, too (Yat getting a ring, and just as he's starting to use it, BLIP, Hallalax takes out the CPB in ET and his ring winks out, having to survive in space somewhere, later witnessing or learning of Daxam's destruction).

All of this said, I say that this issue -- at least told in the context of the Sinestro Corps War issues themselves -- probably should have been done as a special. This probably would have made sense as a "Tales of the Sinestro Corps Presents: Ion" special as opposed to whatever Ron Marz has brewed for next month (which could probably be titled something else, like "Sinestro Corps War Epilogue Special" or such, but I'm straying from the point). Geoff's earlier words from last month's podcast interview were very much on the money and this is almost exactly a mirror to Sodam Yat of what the Superman Prime special was to Superman Prime... sort of a, 2 parts backstory/origin, 1 part War continuation.

Bottom line, the "Green Lantern Corps" title by its definition should probably be an ensemble book populated by and focusing on many Lanterns. This issue -- though I do really like it, and puts any worries about what Tomasi is bringing to the table writing-wise -- literally only focused on a single Green Lantern... and one who isn't even quite a Green Lantern anymore.

Now on the other hand, Tomasi's willingness to devote an entire issue to Yat does give me a bit of hope for what his intentions may or may not be for the handling of Kyle Rayner once he comes to the forefront in the next issue. My biggest fear/concern for Kyle strictly being relegated to an ensemble book like GLC where he can only receive limited attention (which, in my opinion, strips away almost everything that made him relatable to fans originally as opposed to the Hal Jordan years... the attention paid to his personal life, his jobs, his labors, his loves, side-stories, etc.) has always been that even as much as he could shine in it, he will still mostly get lost in the shuffle of the many other GLs he has to share the comic with -- with this issue, there is hope that there may indeed be Kyle-specific issues down the road.

Welcome to the Corps, Peter. Here's looking to the future.

 


Green Lantern® is a registered trademark of DC Comics/Time Warner, © 2007. Copyrighted pictures are © their respective owners.