Enter the Green Lantern Corps Message Board

 

Green Lantern Vol. 4, #31

Published May 29th, 2008
Writer : Geoff Johns
Penciller : Ivan Reis
Inker : Oclair Albert
Cover : Ivan Reis & Dave McCaig

Review by Andrew NDB
of

In short, I know we're only into it up to part 3 of part 6, but I've been waiting for an issue of "Secret Origin" that would truly wow me, that I could truly say that I love.

Found it.

We start off right where we were left with Hammond, Carol, and a newly Green Lanternized Hal Jordan. A very dubious brief interaction with Hammond (where Hammond offers to "help" Hal with his new powers/ring) and Hal is off. Just a brief Hammond appearance here, really, didn't quite deliver on the "Cliffhanger" aspect we were left at the end of the last issue, but that's OK... I suspect he might show up again by the end of this arc.

"I've made it crystal clear I don't date employees," Carol says to Hammond, citing that one dinner date does not make them boyfriend and girlfriend. We're left with the distinct impression that her policy on this is about to change with one Mr. Jordan. Nice writing here.

Hal Jordan returns to Abin Sur's ship and buries him. Well done, and much needed -- many have complained, to great merit I think, that in the last issue Hal just up and left with the ring (even if it kind of self-propelled him) without giving any regard to the dying alien there in the ship... even citing that in previous incarnations of the origin what many loved about it was that here's Hal, this greenhorn human who's never seen an alien, and yet here he was like, "How can I help?" In the last issue Hal didn't pay any regard to Sur or his condition and I can wholly understand this gripe... here, it's somewhat rectified appropriately.

We also get a slight retcon. But wait! It's a sensible one. When Hal sees the dead Abin in his cabin, we see Abin's GL costume slowly dissipating from his body. Why is this a retcon? Well, it's not so much a retcon as it has been a question. In the past decade or so we've had the idea that when a GL slips on a ring, the ring generates the GL costume/uniform, right? And when he takes it off, the costume dematerializes... but not always, right? Here we get a sensible explanation, even if it's not really spelled out for us: if you take off a ring without willing your uniform off, you get to keep the uniform... for a short while. Then it dissipates.

A touching scene. I like Hal by the cairn of rocks with the setting sun in the last panel -- I know I'm a stickler for these things, but I think this is proof that you don't need a whole splash page to make a poignant moment like this resonate.

Jordan is whisked off to Oa for the first time. A double splash page is seen of Oa -- a very yellow Oa, which I am particularly glad for... Geoff isn't ignoring the past -- and we see Hal getting his first glimpse of the Corps. A very stunning moment, the double splash page here is absolutely warranted. The closest comparison I can think of is when Kyle Rayner first caught glimpse of the Corps in their prime back in GL Vol. 3, #100. We get the same amount of, "Holy shit" here, being put into the story to look at it through their eyes.

See some Ch'p. Somewhere, there's like twelve Ch'p fans going, "Yeah!" I like the little bugger, too, and it's good to see him here. The next time we see him, it may be a black ring on his little chipmunk finger!

Hal meets Kilowog. A little less academic than the meeting we were privy to in Emerald Dawn, but nonetheless effective. My greatest fear here was that Geoff would sort of boil down their interaction to just some kind of test of rings, "Who can make the better beam" sort of a thing. Not so. We get a bit of butting heads with the resident drill sergeant (to be expected), but Kilowog does absolutely put Hal in his place.

I am sad, a little, that I think it's kind of being forgotten that Kilowog was originally a scientist. Yes, he's a rough and tough badass drill sergeant instructor... but he was also more than that.

A page of intrigue on Atrocitus being approached by... special ops? The big thing here, and I think the DC Universe #0 too, is the Sector 666 thing. This is a new thing. I get that the Empire of Tears probably spanned many, many sectors and such, but somehow I'd just assumed that all of the people entombed on Ysmault were of Ysmault... which is in Sector 2814. Not really a gripe, just the thoughts running through my head. Eager to learn more about Sector 666, of which Atrocitus was apparently a "survivor" of. I wonder if this ties into when Sinestro was wiping out systems/sectors with the Mad God Sector?

Some great interaction with Hal and Tomar Re. We see glimpses of the Book of Oa where we see actual panels from the "Tales of the Green Lantern Corps Annual" #2 that the Prophecy originated from. Nice touch. A great montage with Hal being shown the ropes, running through various training exercises.

We conclude with Hal earning his GL symbol/badge quite ceremoniously, saying his oath for the first time beside his other GLs. Then we see Sinestro being called in to investigate the death of Abin Sur by Ganthet.

Whom Sinestro is shocked that he has a name. Now this is kind of a retcon in itself. It is reasonable that Guardians don't often/ever tell GLs their names... it is not reasonable that Ganthet is the only/first Guardian to have a name. There's been plenty that have been well documented. To name just one -- I just happen to have Secret Origins #23 from 1988 on my desk -- there was Heru.

And kudos to colorist Randy Mayor! Where was white boots now lay glorious green, and fairly poppy colors. Moose is missed, but I had no quibbles this issue with the colors at all.

Great -- not just good -- issue of GL. My complaints with the issue remain on the "geeky" level, but I absolutely embrace it as the strongest installment in "Secret Origin" so far, by far!

 


Green Lantern® is a registered trademark of DC Comics/Time Warner, © 2008. Copyrighted pictures are © their respective owners.